As the streaming epidemic of disappearing films and series keeps reminding us, the internet isn’t really forever. Unless you own your favorite show or movie on DVD or some other form of physical media, it’s always liable to blink out of existence forever. In recent weeks, however, a few pieces of media have done something far more unnerving than disappear; they’ve changed. Earlier this month, a viral post revealed that the NFL’s YouTube page had uploaded an edited version of Alicia Keys’ Halftime Show to remove a slight voice crack from the official record, stoking fears around A.I. deepfakes and the preservation of reality.
Now, at least on the surface, it appears to have happened again. In January, Lindsay Lohan expressed her disappointment over a joke in Tina Fey’s new Mean Girls musical that referenced the term “fire crotch,” an offensive nickname for the star from the early-2000s. When the film became available to rent and buy digitally last week, some fans noticed that the line had been removed (via USA Today).
But while retroactive edits of this type may stir up some very reasonable fears about fidelity and documentation, this is actually a fairly common—maybe even increasingly—practice in Hollywood with examples dating back years.
2 / 12
Lilo & Stitch
Lilo & Stitch
In 2020, eagle-eyed Disney fans noticed that a scene from Lilo & StitchCinema Blend, Disney made the edit soon after the release of Lilo & Stitch’s first edition DVD, to discourage kids from trying it themselves. [Emma Keates]
3 / 12
Game Of Thrones
Game Of Thrones
Among the many offenses committed by Game Of Thrones’ eighth and final season, few mistakes riled fans up quite as much as the appearance of a forgotten Starbucks coffee cup in the final cut of episode four, right there on a table next to goblets of wine and horns of ale. While the whole incident is pretty funny in retrospect, the errant coffee cup was not long for this world. It was quickly edited out of the episode, and now cannot be found anywhere but YouTube and our hearts. [Emma Keates]
4 / 12
Cats
Cats
Two words: “Butthole Cut.” Yes, the infamous, elusive version of Cats where all the characters have CGI buttholes is real; unfortunately, only a few very lucky people have actually gotten the chance to see it. But feline anuses weren’t the only thing that director Tom Hooper edited out of his misguided masterpiece at the eleventh hour. (Literally. He apparently sent the “completed” version of the film to theaters mere hours before its scheduled New York premiere.) Shortly after it officially opened, Universal reportedly sent another version of the film to theaters with even more corrections, one of them being an extra horrifying shot of Dame Judi Dench in full cat fur with one forgotten human hand, with a wedding ring still visible. Meow, indeed. [Emma Keates]
5 / 12
The Office
The Office
Michael Scott did a lot of deranged things during his time at the helm of Dunder Mifflin’s Scranton branch, but one stunt in particular went a little too far over the line—for NBC, at least. In a now-banned (and pretty hard to find) cold open from season six episode “Koi Pond,” Michael and the rest of the gang in The Office put on a haunted house for local kids in the company’s warehouse. Everything goes pretty much as expected (Darryl doesn’t know who anyone is dressed as, Jim puts in as little effort as possible) until Michael—with an SNL-style gift box taped over his crotch—pretends to hang himself in front of the crowd of screaming children to teach them that suicide is bad. The controversial scene was quickly (and probably rightfully) removed for reruns and DVD releases, and didn’t reappear when the show was added to streaming. [Emma Keates]
6 / 12
Star Wars
Star Wars
There is perhaps no one more famous for changing their work after it’s already been released than George Lucas. Lucas has made all sorts of tweaks to different editions of Star Wars, ranging from minor edits to major overhauls. The shootout between Greedo and Han Solo (Harrison Ford) is one of the most notorious within Star Wars fandom. A more visible change for those less in the know about Jedi lore is the conclusion of Return Of The Jedi, when the spirits of Anakin, Yoda, and Obi-Wan appear; in the theatrical version, Anakin was played by Sebastian Shaw, but on the 2004 special edition DVD release, it’s Hayden Christensen, who played a younger Anakin in the prequel trilogy. “To me, the special edition ones are the films I wanted to make. Anybody that makes films knows the film is never finished. It’s abandoned or it’s ripped out of your hands, and it’s thrown into the marketplace, never finished,” Lucas told MSNBC. “I wanted to actually finish the film the way it was meant to be when I was originally doing it.” [Mary Kate Carr]
7 / 12
Stranger Things
Stranger Things
In 2022, Stranger Things fans suspected that parts of the show may have been edited, including a scene of Jonathan (Charlie Heaton) photographing Nancy (Natalia Dyer) from outside her window while she undressed. That change may have been a Mandela Effect, as the official Twitter/X page of the Stranger Things writers room “no scenes from previous seasons have ever been cut or re-edited.” Yet showrunners Matt and Ross Duffer told Variety they’ve “George Lucas’d things also that people don’t know about.” The duo planned to edit previous scenes to rectify that they’d forgotten Will Byers’ birthday; the outlet also reported that the show’s VFX was still being updated in the weeks after the fourth season premiere “because the Duffer brothers want the show to be as perfect as possible.” [Mary Kate Carr]
8 / 12
Show Dogs
Show Dogs
Show Dogs didn’t exactly rock the world upon its release in 2018, but the family-friendly film did face an unexpected controversy. The film is about an NYPD Rottweiler who goes undercover at a dog show, and in one scene—as happens at dog shows—the dog has its testicles examined. The dog is uncomfortable, but gets through the moment by having what The A.V. Club called a “quasi-psychedelic vision” in our review. But parenting and conservative groups took issue with this depiction, arguing that it made kids more susceptible to grooming if a movie showed a character acquiesce to non-consensual groping. The backlash prompted an apology from the production company, which eventually released a statement saying, “Responding to concerns raised by moviegoers and some specific organizations, Global Road Entertainment has decided to remove two scenes from the film Show Dogs that some have deemed not appropriate for children. The company takes these matters very seriously and remains committed to providing quality entertainment for the intended audiences based on the film’s rating. We apologize to anybody who feels the original version of Show Dogs sent an inappropriate message.” [Mary Kate Carr]
9 / 12
The Rescuers
The Rescuers
There’s a lot of lore about secret naughty images snuck into Disney animated movies, but in 1999 the company was actually forced to recall the home video version of The Rescuers because of an “objectionable background image,” per The Independent. Played at a certain speed, audiences noticed—in just two frames of the film!—an image of a topless woman in a window. The sneaky pseudo-pornographic pic had been part of the movie for 20 years, but it was basically invisible in the theatrical release, and no one noticed it until that home video edition. The lewd lady was taken out of future releases, and you certainly won’t find her in the Disney+ version. [Mary Kate Carr]
10 / 12
2001: A Space Odyssey
2001: A Space Odyssey
Shortly after 2001: A Space Odyssey premiered in 1968, Stanley Kubrick went back into the editing bay and removed about 17 minutes from the film, apparently due to perceived pacing issues. That chunk of the movie would likely be a gold mine to any film buff, but it’s been locked away in a Warner Bros. Vault for years—just how Kubrick would want it, according to his close colleagues. “I truly believe that they should absolutely not do anything to interfere with the film as it is now,” Kurick’s collaborator Leon Vitali told Yahoo! Entertainment. “If anybody has that kind of material, I would hope they’d say, ‘There’s a reason why he didn’t use it.’” [Mary Kate Carr]
11 / 12
Bird Box
Bird Box
Bird Box, starring Sandra Bullock, was a big event film for Netflix in 2019. But in portraying the film’s fictional apocalypse, the streamer accidentally touched a real-life nerve. Stock footage used to depict disaster was taken from a real disaster, the deadly 2013 train crash in Lac-Mégantic, Quebec. Though the streamer faced a lot of criticism for its insensitivity in using the footage of an event that killed an estimated 47 people, Netflix initially declined to make any changes to the film. Eventually, though, the company bowed to pressure: “Netflix and the filmmakers of ‘Bird Box’ have decided to replace the clip,” a spokesperson said in a statement to Variety. “We’re sorry for any pain caused to the Lac-Mégantic community.” [Mary Kate Carr]